Category Romance Review: Forever Mine, Valentine by Vicki Lewis Thompson


Hartman strikes again!

Old Charlie Hartman was out of his mind! To insist that Spence Jegger would marry the first woman he saw on Valentine’s Day was pure madness, given Spence’s opinion of marriage. And an aging vagabond playing St. Valentine was a bit much for even a friend like Spence to accept. Until Charlie pointed out Spence’s “intended,” Jill Amory.

All Jill wanted, however, was to finish painting Valentine messages on the windows of Jegger Outfitters and be on her way. She had a deadline to meet…on the other side of the country. Now all of a sudden two crazy men – one of them the tempting Mr. Jegger himself – seemed determined to influence her schedule…and her heart.


Reviewed by: Introvert Reader


The Book

Vicki Lewis Thompson’s Forever Mine, Valentine was my introduction to the now, sadly, defunct Harlequin Temptations line. The Temptation imprint launched in North America in March 1984. These books were far more sensual in nature than Harlequin’s other series, the Romance, Supperromance, and Presents lines. Temptations featured main characters from all walks of life, not just the rich. They took place anywhere, from small towns to big cities to tropical destinations.

The setting of Forever Mine, Valentine, is mostly in a shopping mall in Colorado, where St. Valentine, himself, is a character in the guise of Charlie Hartmann, a sweet, seemingly doddering, old man.

The Plot

Jill Amory left her old life behind–including a stable dentist boyfriend–to wander across the country on foot, with just a backpack. She paints windows for businesses to earn a little money and has a deadline set to travel through all the States. Jill doesn’t quite know what she wants in life, but she knows it’s not commitment.

Spencer Jegger owns a successful sporting goods store in the mall. He’s athletic, attractive, and friendly to all, including Charlie, who insists that Valentine’s Day miracles are in store for Spence. Charlie tells a disbelieving Spence that he and Jill are destined to be lovers for life. While Spence doesn’t trust in the old man’s predictions, he is interested in Jill.

Spence hires Jill to paint the windows of his store, and in the meantime, he and Jill form a playful relationship with sexual tension just bursting through the surface.

Jill is hesitant about getting close to Spence. He’s an incredibly good-looking man and makes his interest in her known. Jill’s mind is not on settling down, not even for a short while for a love affair. She’s aiming to roam, to search for something, some purpose in life.

Charlie is a cute character, doing just about everything he can to get Spence and Jill together. The two are destined for each other, he fervently declares. Isn’t it Valentine’s season? Doesn’t Jill’s surname “Amory” has the word love in it? That’s more than a mere coincidence. It’s a sign from the heavens above that they’re meant to be! Charlie also has a cute flirtation with an elderly mall-walker, a lady who wouldn’t mind cuddling up to the supposed St. Valentine.

I didn’t understand Jill’s hesitancy towards commitment to Spence and was glad when she decided she knew where her true home was.

Final Analysis of Forever Mine, Valentine

Forever Mine, Valentine left quite a mark on my impressionable younger self. It was this romance that introduced my young mind to real love-making in books. I’d read sex scenes before in V.C. Andrews’ Flowers in the Attic and Stephen King’s Carrie. But they were brief and not as detailed as what I read in this one!

My goodness, I was such a dorky, nerdy bookworm back then. I passed this book around to my friends, spreading the salacious content around in school until one day I got in trouble with my social studies teacher. She took the book away from me in class one day and made a big scene, which was humiliating, although fortunately, that was the worst of it. Well, except for the fact that it earned me a reputation for years as “that girl who reads the sex books.”

Forever Mine, Valentine was a sequel to Be Mine, Valentine, where Charlie had previously wielded Cupid’s bow and arrow to great success. Yes, the old scamp is truly a saint sent from up above!

That’s one aspect I loved about the Temptations. They could have any crazy plot to them or even a simple, mundane one. All kinds of stories were told, with the only qualifier that they were sexually mature enough for a new era of romance readers. This category romance had a hefty dose of humor and lots of steamy love scenes, making it an engaging Valentine’s Day treat.

4 1/2 stars

2 thoughts on “Category Romance Review: Forever Mine, Valentine by Vicki Lewis Thompson”

  1. If I had the financial wherewithal, I would be scooping up all the Harlequin Temptation (and several other Harlequin imprints) of my past as I really loved those books when I was a teenager.

    VLT-as her ubers call her-is still an active writer today, and still publishing great, steamy books.

    1. The Temptations were so good! Silhouette Desires and Bantam Loveswepts, too. All three lines treated their readers with intelligence and maturity and had such diverse plot lines. You could find paranormal elements, tense drama, debates about quotidian ethics, multimillionaires…just about anything and everything in them. Authors had to be quite skilled to be able to pack a lot of punch into 70,000 or so words. VLT was obviously one of them, hence her long career!

Please Drop a Comment and Let's Talk Romance!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top
%d bloggers like this: