Regarding the female protagonist of a romance novel, which heroine is more your style? Do you like to read about a perfect heroine or prefer someone imperfect and real?
This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Sweet Savage Flame earns a small percentage from qualifying purchases.
What Kind of Heroine Do You Prefer to Read About In a Romance?
In a romance novel, what type of heroine do you find most captivating and makes your imagination soar? Do you like reading about an ideal beauty or prefer a character with more imperfections?
Both types of female protagonists have their own appeal. A flawless ideal heroine often embodies qualities that many readers aspire to possess. On the other hand, characters with imperfections can be more relatable and realistic.
What attracts readers to either side of the spectrum? Let’s delve into this and discuss the types of heroines that readers may find in old-school romance books.
The Perfect Heroine
A paragon heroine can create an escapist reading experience for those who enjoy immersing themselves in an idealized world—which makes this type so perfect for the fantasy of the romance genre.
“The Feisty Spitfire”
The classic heroine is a spirited, feisty gal who fearlessly fights for her dreams. Imagine a beauty with a sharp wit and a fiery spirit, unafraid to challenge convention and break free from the shackles of societal expectations. Her determination and courage leave readers breathless as she navigates a world that tries to confine her.
The allure of a flawless and accomplished character can provide a sense of escapism and wish fulfillment. Readers are often drawn to this type of heroine because they enjoy living vicariously through a character who effortlessly succeeds in all aspects of life.
And what an exciting life she leads! This woman embraces every moment and attracts numerous admirers while embarking on thrilling adventures.
“The Mary Sue”
A “Mary Sue” heroine is typically an author or reader insert or an idealized character who excels at everything she does. She is often portrayed as a beautiful woman who is admired and desired by many men. Moreover, she has wonderful innate qualities as she is kind-hearted, intelligent, and confident.
The appeal of a “Mary Sue” heroine lies in her ability to overcome challenges and achieve extraordinary feats. This can inspire readers and instill a sense of empowerment, motivating them to pursue their own goals and dreams.
Furthermore, the admiration and desire the character receives from others can create a sense of validation and self-worth for readers. Witnessing a universally admired and wanted character can evoke positive emotions and boost the reader’s self-esteem.
Where to Find This Heroine:
She is often found in bodice rippers, and Harlequin Presents for Silhouette Desires. The stories are larger-than-life, epic, angsty, and emotional reads.
The late Bertrice Small almost always wrote about flawless heroines who were larger than life and had multiple love interests. Skye O’Malley is a legendary, perfect heroine.
The Imperfect Heroine
Not all readers prefer the perfect or ideal type of heroine. Many may appreciate an “imperfect” heroine and relatable characters who have flaws and face realistic struggles. This protagonist may not be conventionally beautiful, but the hero can’t help but think she’s the greatest. She inspires audiences to know that love is for everyone, not just perfect people.
Introducing an “imperfect” heroine and relatable characters with flaws and realistic struggles can add depth and authenticity to a story. Seeing a protagonist who may not conform to conventional beauty standards but is still adored and respected by the hero, the reader feels that love knows no bounds.
An unconventional beauty challenge norms and remind audiences that love transcends physical appearances. People enjoy stories affirming that love is inclusive and should be accessible to everyone, regardless of how society perceives them.
This heroine is more prevalent in modern romances than old-school ones, as contemporary readers seek affirmation in their escapism rather than pure fantasy elements. (Unless they are reading a “fantasy romance,” of course!)
Audiences want imperfect characters who confront realistic challenges as they reflect the complexities of real life. These stories have valuable lessons about self-acceptance, compassion for others’ flaws, and the power of love in all its forms.
Where to Find This Heroine:
This type of heroine usually inhabits contemporary category lines. These include Silhouette Special Editions and Harlequin American Romances.
An excellent example of this is Reina from Johanna Lindsey‘s Medieval romance, Defy Not The Heart.
The Complicated Woman
But what about a more complex heroine who possesses both conventional beauty and a “down-to-earth” personality?
This character possesses a wide range of possibilities. With her intriguing nature, she can effortlessly embody the persona of an ordinary woman with a mysterious aura, leaving others intrigued by her enigmatic charm. On the other hand, she also can portray a stunning and sensational individual with a life full of scandals and captivating tales.
Alternatively, she can be depicted as an “ugly duckling” who transforms remarkably into a beautiful swan. This narrative arc captivates readers as they witness her journey from an overlooked or underestimated nobody to blossoming into someone genuinely enchanting.
Then again, this character can evolve from an initially unassuming, dowdy duck into…the loveliest of ducks! Her features stay the same, but her inner beauty shines through as she radiates warmth and charm. This transformation showcases the power of self-discovery and embracing one’s true essence.
This heroine possesses a rare ability to heal the wounds of others, offering solace and understanding. Conversely, she can be a woman with a dark past and needs the hero’s gentle healing touch.
Where to Find This Heroine:
This heroine can be found in many genres. She is often in the Romantic Suspense or Gothic genres.
One notable complicated heroine is Emily Lamb from Roberta Leigh’s Temporary Wife or Melanie from Miranda Lee’s Passion and the Past.
Final Thoughts On Heroines In Romances
From spirited rebels to compassionate healers and quick-witted intellectuals to resilient souls, romance novels offer an array of captivating heroines to suit every taste.
Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference regarding the kind of heroine you appreciate most. Some readers may prefer escapism by delving into the world of flawless ideals, while others might enjoy connecting with characters who reflect real-life complexities.
Whatever type of heroine you choose will depend on what resonates most strongly with your target audience’s desires and expectations in romance novels.
Your Opinion
Where do you stand on this topic? Regarding romance novels, do you prefer a female protagonist who is perfect or flawed? We’d love to hear what you think!
As always, please drop a comment, and let’s talk romance.
Interesting question. Can’t stand heroines that tolerate disrespect. A story reflecting growth of the character is my choice. Perfection not required. I do want the FMC to be somewhat attractive though. I know- that’s weak. But great beauty isn’t required. Also want the MMC to be a cuddly sweetheart.
What kind of heroine I prefer depends upon my mood when I read romance since that varies I would have to say both. I will usually read several perfect heroine types and then when I have had my fill of test switch to the other kind.